this post was submitted on 21 Apr 2025
112 points (100.0% liked)
Technology
40509 readers
352 users here now
A nice place to discuss rumors, happenings, innovations, and challenges in the technology sphere. We also welcome discussions on the intersections of technology and society. If it’s technological news or discussion of technology, it probably belongs here.
Remember the overriding ethos on Beehaw: Be(e) Nice. Each user you encounter here is a person, and should be treated with kindness (even if they’re wrong, or use a Linux distro you don’t like). Personal attacks will not be tolerated.
Subcommunities on Beehaw:
This community's icon was made by Aaron Schneider, under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 license.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
People with your attitude are a significant reason why people decide against Linux. It's doing Microsoft a service.
and people like me are why Linux has even gotten to where it's at today.
Consumers don't make software, developers do.
Well, are you a developer?
I am. I have written software, both open source and commercial, for almost twenty years now and the most important lesson I have learned in that time is that developers alone don’t write good software. You need to listen to UI/UX experts, testers and user feedback to make something that people actually want to use.
Developers don't have to be so arrogant. In fact stuff like this pushes other developers away too.
Not to mention from what I've heard GIMP just doesn't compare to the paid options for professional work.
Not true. There are tons of nice developers out there. And I for one wouldn't want to work in a team where an attitude like yours is prevalent.
Your comment made me realize I'm (and I'm sure I'm not alone) sort of the problem with Linux.
Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love the massive community of tools and programs out there like free open source software. But I've never actually bought anything for a Linux system with one exception: Debian in a box, on a CD for like, $15.
Buuuut, I have bought FOSS, games, and utilities for Mac and Windows that started as Linux apps and work on my new system.
I guess there is a mindset of get something free to suffice with Linux systems rather than pay for polished apps, and I totally get that thrill, but is there business to be made in this market, or a sunk cost at the end of the year.
I'd really like to see the app, and it takes bold risks to populate this platform, and there's certainly pushback, but that's also what separates Linux from windows. No point in having a machine if there are gaps in workflow or utility.
Remember, boys and girls, Steam bringing its monopoly to Linux is a victory, but wanting literally any other closed source software is "pathetic".
Yet another reminder that the worst thing about Linux is its users.
I tried again and again to do the things I need to do with gimp but it still lacks many features and the ones it does have are hard to use. Sometimes it’s not about ideology but about needing to get shit done.
Tried Gimp 3.0?
Just for maybe an hour or so, haven’t had time for more. It seems a bit better but still too different from everything else to assume people can „just“ use it instead of the solution they are familiar with.
Gimp really needs the kind of in-depth UI/UX redesign that blender got with 2.8.
Don't try to do client work bound to a deadline on gimp. Because the stress will make you close gimp at the simplest inconvenience. That's what happened to me. But trying to work with it on my free time. And installing the photogimp addon helped alot. Gimp still has a long way to go.
So what do I do when I need to get something done on a deadline? VM? Dualboot? Just give up?
Please don't interpret that as an attack, it's a serious question. I would love to fully move to linux. I've put Arch on my laptop about a month ago as an experiment and overall it works great. But every time I need to be productive, I hit a wall. Especially with photo editing but even for software development (mostly C# and C++), Windows 10 + WSL feels like the better choice.
My comment wasn't about specifically using gimp on Linux and dumping Mac and windows. But just about how to getting used to gimp in general.
Linux is still lacking many other professional grade software so even you find a PS replacement on linux. Other software problems might pop up.
I had only read that there were changes under the hood and also in the UI/UX. I hadn't tested it yet and thought I'd just ask. It could have been that you had also only used the older versions and now there might have been changes.
If you ever used Affinity/Adobe products and GIMP on any capacity over just trying to crop an image, you'd never say something like this. GIMP, despite its 3.0 release, is still decades behind those other programs.
GIMP feels like it's made by software engineers for software engineers, trying to play catch up with the other softwares available that were made with designers and artists in mind.
You know, downcasting and/or insulting people just because they don't live up to your personal standards is a pretty shitty thing to do.
Also, guessing their standard is pretty low if Gimp does the job — at least from a professional standard. There's not much of a comparison.
Gimp is a pile of garbage, please don't recommend people use it.
It needs a full rewrite (preferably by others) for it to function like a modern digital image editor.
The name is just a nugget on the shitpile.