PC Gaming

The article says it’s a 2002 laptop and says it would have been “significantly out of date” when Half-Life 2 launched. Half-Life 2 launched in 2004. So that’s 2 years. He’s also reduced the resolution to 512x512 - less than half the original resolution - and hasn’t recreated several of the lighting effects.

I don’t know what unoptimised games this is supposed to be a middle finger to specifically, but it strikes me that it wouldn’t be considered particularly out of the ordinary to find a modern game that could run on a 2023 machine at less than half resolution and with significantly reduced lighting effects.

Very cool, but hopefully nobody actually thinks this proves anything on the game optimization debate, right? It's not like Half Life 2 is the graphical standard most gamers expect nowadays. But if you are content with this graphics, I assure you even recent releases that look like that will perform great, so...

Half Life 2 was released over 20 years ago. It was meant to run on what is now regarded as ancient hardware.

When Half Life 2 released there was actually a whole lot of grumbling from gamers as the system requirements were very high. It ran like shit or didn't ran at all unless you had very recent and high end hardware.

I remember buying a new gpu back then specifically because of HL2. I didn't have a lot of money, so I bought an Asus 6800 card, which wasn't powerful enough to run HL2. However with a bit of luck those could be modded and overclocked into an 6800 Ultra which was powerful enough. However it was a lottery whether this was possible and ran without issues. The first card I bought couldn't do it, so I went to the shop and returned it. Went to another shop and bought one there, which also didn't work. Then I went over to another town and bought one there which finally worked out. Even though it was a mid-tier card, gpus were expensive back then so it cost me all of the money I'd saved up for a couple of years before.

HL2 has gotten a lot of optimizations as the years went on, but when it first released it was an example of an unoptimized game when released. And just like these days people were bitching about it.

So, Black Mesa?

I recall the physics being the big deal with HL2. Graphics were also great for the time.

Well, there are some 'poorly optimised' games out there. Am able to run eg. Cyberpunk 2077 near maximum (non-raytraced) settings and it happily trundles along at 80+ fps. Would really like to play Mind Over Magic, just my kind of game and which looks like it was done on the Quake3 engine, and I'm struggling since it runs like absolute ass regardless of what the settings are. Think that's the joy of Unity, though.

I think a lot of the problem is that we're long past the point where diminishing returns kick in. Doubling the amount of processing required for a few percent more lighting fidelity, that kind of thing. Half Life 2 was expensive for its day, mostly due to its extended development - about $40m then, equivalent of ~$70m now - but it still looks great, mostly due to its strong art style. (I realise Valve keep sneakily updating the engine, so things like the water effects are much better now than they were on release.) There's games that cost ten times as much and which don't really look a lot better, but which will get tagged as 'badly optimised' since they're chasing the very latest graphical shinies.

I think the sheer price of producing all of those HD assets is a significant risk to any studio, and means that we end up with a lot of cookie-cutter AAA games where the industry is very cautious about taking chances of any kind. Maybe I'm not the main target for the shiniest of graphics, but my Steam games with the most hours - Dwarf Fortress, Oxygen Not Included, the Dark Souls series, Crusader Kings - run the gamut from 'charmingly simple' to 'functionally realistic', but I'd not describe any of them as great because of their graphics.

Btw, that the isometric game Above Snakes runs worse than any hobby Unity game from itch, is this a wine (linux) thing or is the game just shit?

Rose tinted glasses.