this post was submitted on 07 Sep 2025
114 points (98.3% liked)
science
21656 readers
142 users here now
A community to post scientific articles, news, and civil discussion.
rule #1: be kind
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The lack of a magnetic field was always going to prevent that, Musk was just a moron.
Eh, it’s a problem but my understanding is that atmospheric loss should be quite slow. The challenge of creating an atmosphere in the first place is nearly insurmountable but assuming we’re able to do that, there’s no reason it couldn’t be gradually replenished.
I mean we were never going to see the result of a complete terraform of Mars to begin with even if it went perfect with theoretical technology. I doubt our great great grandchildren would have seen it either. I was speculating on the long term. Flying colonies on Venus might be the best bet for long term 2nd human planet.
Agreed on all counts. Yeah, Mars was never really a good candidate for colonies, despite being technically the most earth-like planet.
Realistically, terraforming Mars would probably be something like a 3000 year project. But to me, that doesn't mean it's 3000 years away, it means it will actually never happen. Given the ever increasing pace of technology, I can't actually see a 3000 year project like that ever completing, because in that time the human race, and our goals would have changed immensely. We're already successfully editing plant and animal genomes, at some point we will have changed ourselves so much that the goal we aimed for a millennia ago no longer makes sense. We likely won't need an earth-like planet in the same way.
At any rate, I think space habitats are the way of the future, O'Neil cylinders and the like. Once you make it all the way to space, why trap yourself all the way down another gravity well?
"just give me a few hundred megatons of nuclear weapons and we can restart the core on Mars guys"
Could an artificial field be created?
It would require more energy than we can produce at the moment.
What if we nuke something?
/s
There's is a video from 'Kurzgesagt' I think it was that explains why it's more realistic to settle Venus instead of Mars.
Edit: Found it