You decided to shut off your brain. It’s illegal to criticize the war as a Russian. That isn’t true of Ukraine or it’s supporters. So you’re making a false comparison.

Are you just saying that russia could lie about western journalists? They can do that new, or whenever, or always. They’re dishonest about that kind of thing all the time, and they have broken so many international laws with this war that being worried that this could be their big opening to start breaking the law is just silly. So silly that I don’t think you’re arguing in good faith.

[–] Addfwyn@lemmy.ml 1 points 2 years ago

That isn’t true of Ukraine or it’s supporters.

Journalists have been jailed for exactly that in Ukraine and some NATO countries though, so it is definitely true for some of those places.

[–] redtea@lemmygrad.ml 1 points 2 years ago

I'll try to make this point even more directly: killing journalists is a war crime.

There are some occasions when this war crime is excused. For example, when there is no other choice and the the killing is proportionate to the achievement of some other legitimate aim but only if the civilians have been warned effectively. That exception does not appear to apply in the instant circumstances because the victims (one died, three were injured) were all journalists.

Facts that do not alter this conclusion:

The journalist being a propagandist;
Having one's 'own side' commit the same or other war crimes;
The legality of the war;
The proximity of actual soldiers;
The extent to which this law is enforced or enforceable.

The reason I am talking about the killing of a Russian journalist is because he is the subject of the linked article in the post.

End of main point.

If the accusation of being a propagandist justified the killing of journalists, it would also negate the criminal aspect of any such killings by Russia. Russia could simply claim that western journalists are propagandists. It is irrelevant that you think all Russian journalists are propagandists because they will same the same in reverse. Westerners are not entitled to be the sole arbiters of which side is right. Further, there's no 'if' because being a propagandist does not justify the killing of journalists, according to international law.

On another occasion, I would enjoy talking through the state of western and Russian media but for now it is a red herring and is obfuscating the main point.