this post was submitted on 23 Oct 2023
77 points (96.4% liked)

World News

32348 readers
477 users here now

News from around the world!

Rules:

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] SinAdjetivos@beehaw.org 3 points 1 year ago

No they don't... You do and the media is engaged in a terrifying amount of manufactured consent, but the raw data from those same polls does not agree with that claim.

Ignoring the sampling methods used, lack of transparency on filters and other methodology, clearly biased questions, etc. The latest CBS news poll on the topic lists:

  • 52% believe less weapons and supplies should be sent to Israel.

  • 76% believe more humanitarian aid should be sent to Israel.

  • 57% believe more humanitarian aid should be sent to Gaza.

  • 56% disapprove of how the situation with Russia and Ukraine is being handled. (Though there isn't much of a breakdown on the "how is it being mishandled...")

A few things that should be explicitly pointed out as this is a bad poll, but it would appear the inherit bias is trying to agree with you, so the margin of error means the "true feelings of Americans" is even further in contradiction to your statement.

  • Note how Isreal is kept consistent without a single reference to Netanyahu/Israeli government compared to the constant switching back and forth between "Hamas" and "Palestinian people"

  • poll is 63% white, 62% of that group has "no degree", 33% aged between 45-64 (amongst 4 categories).

So even when polling predominantly uneducated* white baby boomers who are the exact demographic that agrees the most with you, and doing the typical statistical magic the numbers still cannot be finagled in such a way as to make your statement true.

  • it should be said that "uneducated" doesn't necessarily mean 'uninformed, stupid, etc.' However, in this context it means they are deliberately polling non-experts who's primary source of information is CBS/Paramount itself (or other closely related corporations) in order to manufacture consent.