139
If a real working class party includes these people I’d rather watch the world burn in hellfire
(hexbear.net)
this post was submitted on 22 Oct 2025
139 points (100.0% liked)
Chapotraphouse
14152 readers
632 users here now
Banned? DM Wmill to appeal.
No anti-nautilism posts. See: Eco-fascism Primer
Slop posts go in c/slop. Don't post low-hanging fruit here.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
That's a marketing metric the military likes to brag about.... But it's a bit misleading. They say 60% come from a middle class and 20% from below middle class.... However, they consider any household with an income from 38k -86k is middle class, which is a bit of a spread.
I mean that's just kinda ahistorical? Most of the higher up military in the Soviet Republic also served the Tsar. Was Georgy Zhukov not communist enough for us? What about Hugo Chavez?
My rebuttal and defense was against the general rejection of all military members, not any specific one. Obviously there needs to be context and nuance when evaluating individual character and whether or not someone has turned a new leaf.
Zhukov and Chavez proved their worth on the battlefield putting their lives on the line in combat against their former anticommunist masters (who were arguably less genocidal than the usa).
I don't have much experience with small leftist orgs in the imperial core but I'd think imagine its both good security and basic solidarity with the people america genocides to not have fascist soldiers who have been probably indoctrinated by deed and brainwashing anywhere near positions of leadership in a small leftist org at the stage of struggle that does not require armed combat.
Its an expression of rightful disdain at one of the world's worst fascist militaries who have never stopped committing genocide from the founding of their settler colony till now. Many people outside of america and its allies hate the us military to hell because the us military is often pointing guns at them, just like how everyone hates cops within the imperial core. They are the west's occupation force for the third world. For many, the reality is that they are a genocidal force to be fought off.
I really don't know about the Tsar being less genocidal, like the dude got pulled up a river by slaves trudging through hip deep mud with ropes attached to their fucking foreheads. If he had the resources America had the world would be fundamentally worse than it is now purely because the landowner class is more depraved and reactionary than the bourgeoisie
If anything, the Tsar is about as genocidal as the confederacy, which I think most can agree is far worse than the USA at the time.
Yeah I was referring more to the scale and length of the genocidal regimes plus the general depravity of the us military, sorry didn't mean to minimize how evil the Tsar was, the Bolsheviks did a lot of good by destroying the tsarist empire.